How New York Lottery Turned Scratch-Off Stakes Into a Thumb Wars Showdown
New York Lottery's "Thumb Wars" is a 2013 film campaign created by DDB New York and produced by MJZ, directed by The Perlorian Brothers, that dramatises the multiplier outcomes of scratch-off games through the universal, playful lens of a thumb-wrestling contest, translating abstract prize mechanics into an instantly recognisable physical rivalry for a broad United States audience.
Published in January 2013, the campaign centres on a single film asset built around a deceptively simple conceit: the tension of a scratch-off multiplier made visceral and comedic through thumb wars. The approach reflects DDB's continuing creative philosophy for the New York Lottery account, which had long favoured humour, recognisable everyday situations, and characters that cut through the noise of a crowded gaming and entertainment landscape in the United States. Rather than leading with jackpot figures or aspirational lifestyle imagery — the default register of much lottery advertising — "Thumb Wars" roots its appeal in physical comedy and the kind of competitive play familiar to virtually every adult consumer.
The campaign sits within the scratch-off game category, where multiplier mechanics are a primary purchase driver but notoriously difficult to communicate with warmth or wit. By translating that mechanic into the language of thumb wrestling, DDB New York gave the New York Lottery a culturally accessible shorthand that required no financial literacy to decode. The creative team behind the work included Chief Creative Officer Matt Eastwood, Group Creative Directors Richard Sharp and Mike Sullivan, and Head of Production Ed Zazzera, all operating from DDB's New York office. Production was handled by MJZ, one of the most consistently decorated commercial production companies working in the United States market, with direction by The Perlorian Brothers, a directing duo known for comedy-driven performance work. The campaign received a Clapboard Score of 63 out of 100.
New York Lottery operates in one of the most competitive state gaming markets in the United States. According to Apps Cio Ny Gov, New York Lottery and video-lottery activity generated approximately $9.23 billion in fiscal year 2013–14, an increase of around 4.2 percent from fiscal year 2012–13, and returned approximately $3.17 billion to education funding. Traditional New York Lottery sales specifically rose approximately 2.9 percent, or $205.3 million, in fiscal 2013–14, per the same source. These figures place the New York Lottery among the highest-volume state lottery operations in the country, competing not only with neighbouring state lotteries but also with the expanding footprint of commercial casinos and digital gaming options increasingly available to consumers across the United States.
"Thumb Wars" did not emerge from a blank creative slate. According to Clapboard's editorial research, the campaign belonged to DDB's established strategic approach of using humorous, recognisable characters and everyday situations to sell New York Lottery products. The most direct predecessor was the "Little Bit of Luck" campaign, which introduced a recurring character for the Take 5 game in 2008 and was expanded in May 2012 to promote multiple games including Powerball, Sweet Million, and Quick Pick, according to Gaming Ny Gov. That 2012 expansion involved approximately 25 actors wearing masks modelled on a single character's face, per the same source — a production commitment signalling sustained creative investment in comedic character-driven work. "Thumb Wars" continued this lineage but pivoted from character-based comedy to situation-based comedy, using a universally understood game rather than a proprietary mascot as its hook.
The strategic rationale is legible. In the United States, state lottery advertising operates under strict regulatory and reputational constraints, requiring campaigns to entertain without overpromising. According to Oa Mo Gov, the average state lottery advertising budget runs to approximately $14.0 million per lottery — a substantial but not unlimited resource in a media environment where competitors such as the Florida Lottery and the Multi-State Lottery Association's Powerball brand command significant national visibility. Within those constraints, humour that travels broadly and production craft that elevates a simple premise represent efficient creative investments.
The Perlorian Brothers directed "Thumb Wars" for New York Lottery through MJZ. The Perlorian Brothers are a Canadian directing duo — Chris and Paul Perlorian — represented by MJZ and recognised across the advertising industry for their ability to sustain comedic escalation within tightly controlled commercial formats. Their work characteristically begins with a mundane social situation and amplifies it through performance and precise editing rhythm until the absurdity becomes the entire point. "Thumb Wars" fits that template exactly: a simple physical contest between two thumbs stands in for the genuine competitive stakes of a scratch-off multiplier, with the comedy derived from treating the trivial as gravely consequential.
The creative leadership at DDB New York structured the production around a team with clear role definition. Matt Eastwood held the position of Chief Creative Officer, with Richard Sharp and Mike Sullivan serving as Group Creative Directors. Aron Fried and Carlos Wigle served as Associate Creative Directors, providing the conceptual layer closest to the execution. Ed Zazzera, as Head of Production at DDB New York, oversaw the agency side of the production process, with Walter Brindak serving as Executive Producer on the DDB side. Account stewardship was managed by Leo Mamorsky as Group Account Director and Kelly Gorsky as Management Supervisor, per Clapboard's production credits documentation.
MJZ as a production company brings a consistent standard of technical and performance direction to comedy-driven commercial work. The choice of MJZ for a campaign built entirely around physical comedy performance reflects a deliberate pairing of concept and craft — the joke only works if the thumb-wrestling is shot and performed with enough commitment to earn the comedic escalation. For a single-asset film campaign in January 2013, the production values needed to carry the full weight of the creative idea without supporting elements. According to Clapboard's archive documentation, "Thumb Wars" contains one media asset, meaning the film was required to function as a complete, self-contained communication.
No verified performance data for the "Thumb Wars" campaign is publicly available. No published business results, media effectiveness studies, or consumer response metrics have been located across trade sources including Ad Age, Adweek, Campaign, The Drum, or Contagious, and no attributed commentary from the DDB creative team or New York Lottery marketing leadership has been documented in connection with this specific campaign. The campaign does not appear in verified award finalist or winner listings at Cannes Lions, the Effie Awards, The One Show, D&AD, the Clio Awards, or the Webby Awards, per Clapboard's awards research.
Structurally, however, the campaign's effectiveness logic is coherent. The thumb-wars conceit solves a genuine communication problem — making a multiplier mechanic feel exciting and immediate — without resorting to the hyperbolic jackpot imagery that tends to erode trust with experienced lottery players. The campaign's single-asset format, directed by The Perlorian Brothers through MJZ, concentrates creative and production resource into one tightly crafted film, a format that rewards strong concept and performance direction over media weight. In a market where, according to apps.cio.ny.gov, New York Lottery traditional sales were growing at approximately 2.9 percent year-on-year in the period surrounding this campaign, maintaining brand warmth and category relevance through entertainment-led advertising represents a defensible strategic position. The Clapboard Score of 63 out of 100 reflects solid creative craft and a clear strategic rationale, offset by limited public documentation of reach, impact, or industry recognition.
"Thumb Wars" is a 2013 film campaign for New York Lottery created by DDB New York. It dramatises scratch-off multiplier game outcomes through the comedic device of thumb wrestling. Directed by The Perlorian Brothers via MJZ, the campaign launched in January 2013 in the United States as a single-asset film.
The Perlorian Brothers directed "Thumb Wars" through production company MJZ. The Perlorian Brothers are a directing duo known for comedy-driven commercial work. The DDB New York creative team was led by Chief Creative Officer Matt Eastwood, with Group Creative Directors Richard Sharp and Mike Sullivan overseeing the campaign.
DDB New York used physical comedy to make scratch-off multiplier mechanics immediately understandable and entertaining. The strategy continued DDB's established approach for New York Lottery of using humour and everyday situations rather than jackpot-led aspirational messaging, building on a lineage that included the earlier Little Bit of Luck campaign.
"Thumb Wars" extended DDB's humour-led creative approach for New York Lottery, which dated back to the Little Bit of Luck character introduced in 2008 for the Take 5 game, according to gaming.ny.gov. The 2013 campaign shifted from character-based to situation-based comedy while maintaining the same accessible, entertainment-first creative register.
No verified award wins or finalist listings for "Thumb Wars" have been documented at major shows including Cannes Lions, the Clio Awards, D&AD, The One Show, or the Effie Awards, per Clapboard's awards research. The campaign received a Clapboard Score of 63 out of 100, reflecting solid craft without recorded industry recognition.
New York Lottery generated approximately $9.23 billion in combined lottery and video-lottery revenue in fiscal 2013–14, returning approximately $3.17 billion to education, according to apps.cio.ny.gov. Traditional lottery sales in New York grew approximately 2.9 percent that fiscal year, situating "Thumb Wars" within a steadily growing but competitive United States state gaming market.
.webp)
Creative Collaboration Platform: The Backbone of Modern Creative WorkWhat is a creative collaboration platform?Clapboard defines a creative collaboration platform as the operational core for today’s distributed creative teams. This is not a collection of digital collaboration tools stitched together; Clapboard’s system
Understanding the Creative Production MarketplaceWhat is a Creative Production Marketplace?Clapboard defines a creative production marketplace as a structured ecosystem where brands, agencies, and production talent converge to execute video, advertising, and branded content at scale. Unlike the legacy agency or freelanREAD FULL ARTICLE
The Urgent Need for a Creative Production Operating SystemWhy Traditional Creative Production Models Break DownClapboard sees the creative production landscape shifting under pressure. Content velocity is no longer a buzzword—it’s a mandate. Modern advertising demands relentless output across dozens of channels, each wREAD FULL ARTICLE
